Talk:Battlecruiser Squadron 5

Back to page

8,446pages on
this wiki
Add New Page
Add New Page

Revolutionary reedition Edit

Please assure me Captain Dournet on the position of CO, BCD 51, is deduction, not a direct proof (quotation) (as well as HMS Irrestible in first division) - I suggest such supposition should be revealed in references

Question - why "Squadron flagship", and "Division flagship" phrases should be started with capital letter?

Comment - information concerning cruisers classes is lost.

--dotz 08:03, 30 August 2009 (UTC)

Explanation of my changes Edit

...if not selfexplaining:

  • at least some two digit divisions numbers were mentioned in BCR 5 as well as in other BCRs, so such way of numbering is at least equally right to one digit numbering; IMO it is much easier to identify it like eg. BCD 51 (battlecruiser division fifty one) than I/BCR 5 (first division of the battlecruiser squadron five); (this is Honorverse with hazy rules established by wrighters, real-word kownledge is supportive tool only; way of numbering you suggested origins from real-world land units organization I suppose)
  • your clear "four divisions scheme" don't cover initial phase of BCR 5 history (squadron in statu nascendi). Status during servce in HFleet is much improved now I hope (I think better idea is to describe changes in organization within whole squadron frame, than at divisions sections).
  • we don't know all members of staff, Moreau inherited it, so it should be extracted from your time divisions.

--dotz 08:03, 30 August 2009 (UTC)

What exactly ships were heavily damaged in Hancock? Edit

It seems not Nike, while she was able to be sent out.--dotz 08:21, 30 August 2009 (UTC)

Seniority Edit

HH was junior tp six of the seven other BC captains. HH3--dotz 15:25, November 3, 2009 (UTC)

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki